What Reviewers Say

Bookshark is widely regarded as the premier secular alternative to Sonlight, maintaining a heavy emphasis on high-quality literature and "real books" rather than textbooks. Reviewers across Cathy Duffy and The Homeschool Mom consistently praise the Instructor's Guide for being truly "open-and-go," requiring virtually no prep time from parents. The 4-day week schedule is frequently cited as a major benefit, allowing for flexibility on the fifth day. However, a common critique found in Reddit discussions and user forums is the sheer volume of reading, which can feel like a "slog" for reluctant readers or busy families. While the academic rigor is high, the cost is a significant barrier for some, as full packages represent a major investment. It is highly effective for families who love reading together but may be overwhelming for those who prefer hands-on or kinesthetic learning.

How It Works

Using BookShark feels like a guided book club at your kitchen table, where the parent follows a pre-organized four-day schedule found in the Instructor’s Guide. Each day, the parent reads aloud from high-quality literature or 'living books,' while the child engages in discussions, map work, and hands-on science experiments. Depending on the grade level, a session can last from two to five hours, with older students transitioning to more independent reading while parents remain the primary discussion leaders. The fifth day is intentionally left blank, allowing families to catch up on errands, explore hobbies, or take a day off.

Switching to This?

BookShark offers free online placement tests for Reading and Math, but because their levels cover a broad age range, parents should primarily consult the 'Age Range' charts on their website. A common community tip is to prioritize the child’s reading comprehension over their actual grade level, as the volume of literature can be overwhelming if the student is placed too high. While it is possible to start mid-year, most families find it best to start at the beginning of a level because the history and science narratives follow a chronological sequence. If you are coming from a textbook-based program, expect to spend more time reading together and less time filling out worksheets.

Curriculum Details

Price

$480 - $1250

Prices vary by "Level" and package type. All-Subject Packages are more expensive, while "Reading with History" packages are lower. Individual subjects can be purchased separately.

Grades

PRE-K - 12

Available As

Print Digital Workbook Video

Coverage

All subjects

Subjects

Math Science History/Social Studies Reading/Language Arts Writing

---

Pacing

Some flexibility

Parent Time

60-180 min/day

Parent Involvement

Minimal

Student Independence

Semi-independent

---

Academic Level

Above grade level

Worldview

Secular

Teach Multiple Ages

Yes

Parent Role:

Parent reads aloud and discusses books with children (1-3 hours daily). Instructor guide is "open and go" with minimal prep. Parent facilitates activities and checks work.

Videos

Reviews We Consulted

Updated: March 2026

How This Compares

The most frequent comparison is to Sonlight, where the core difference is that BookShark is strictly secular, offering the same literature-based structure without the religious instruction or perspectives. Compared to Build Your Library, BookShark provides a physical 'box' experience with all books and a pre-printed binder included, making it better for parents who want zero-prep convenience over the lower-cost but more labor-intensive sourcing required by other programs. When choosing between BookShark and Oak Meadow, families find BookShark is more academically rigorous and reading-focused, whereas Oak Meadow is better for students who need artistic expression and a slower, Waldorf-inspired pace.

Getting Started