What Reviewers Say

Sabbath Mood Homeschool (SMH) Science is widely celebrated by the Charlotte Mason community for filling a long-standing gap in high-quality, literature-based science instruction. Reviewers from Cathy Duffy to users on The Homeschool Mom consistently highlight the curriculum's shift away from 'dry textbooks' in favor of 'living books' that foster a genuine love for the subject. A recurring theme in feedback—particularly on the Well-Trained Mind forums—is that while the approach is gentle, the content is surprisingly rigorous, often exceeding the depth of traditional programs for similar grade levels. However, the most cited trade-off is the logistical burden; parents must source their own books, some of which are out-of-print or expensive, and manage the collection of lab materials. While the study guides are affordable, the total cost of a year's curriculum can be high due to these external book requirements.

How It Works

A typical week involves two to three sessions lasting 20 to 45 minutes, depending on the child's age and the specific science topic chosen. For younger students, the parent reads aloud from a high-quality 'living book'—a narrative-style book written by an enthusiast—while the child provides an oral narration to explain what they learned. Older students read independently and complete written narrations or sketches in a science notebook to document their findings. Each lesson is guided by a PDF study guide that directs the parent on which pages to read and when to perform hands-on experiments using a pre-listed set of household or lab supplies. The week concludes with the student recording observations in a nature journal or finishing a lab report, with the parent acting as a co-explorer and facilitator rather than a lecturer.

Switching to This?

Sabbath Mood Homeschool does not provide formal placement tests, as the curriculum is organized by Charlotte Mason 'Forms' rather than strict grade levels: Form 1 is for grades 1-3, Form 2 for grades 4-6, Form 3 for grades 7-9, and Form 4 for grades 10-12. Parents should place their child based on these age ranges, though those new to the Charlotte Mason method may want to start with a single subject module to practice the art of narration before adding more. Because the program is modular, families can easily start mid-year by simply picking up a new 11-week study guide. If you are switching from a traditional textbook, be prepared for a shift in focus from memorizing terms to discussing big ideas and relationship-building with the natural world.

Curriculum Details

Price

$15 - $250

Study guides range from $15 to $20 each. Full-year bundles of guides are available for approximately $50-$60. Costs significantly increase when purchasing the required living books and lab supplies separately.

Grades

1 - 12

Available As

Digital Print

Coverage

Single subject

Subjects

Science

---

Pacing

Flexible

Parent Time

20-45 min/day

Parent Involvement

Minimal

Student Independence

Semi-independent

---

Academic Level

Above grade level

Worldview

Christian

Teach Multiple Ages

Yes

Engaging for Reluctant Learners

Yes

Videos

Reviews We Consulted

Updated: March 2026

How This Compares

Compared to Apologia, which focuses on one major branch of science for an entire year, Sabbath Mood Homeschool allows students to rotate through multiple shorter modules, which keeps the subject fresh for students with varied interests. When weighed against Noeo Science, SMH is often seen as more rigorous in the upper grades, though Noeo offers the convenience of pre-packaged experiment kits that SMH lacks. Compared to Berean Builders, which follows a chronological history of science, SMH is organized by topic (like Botany or Physics), making it easier for parents to align science with their child's specific curiosities. Against Simply Charlotte Mason’s science modules, SMH provides more robust and structured support for the high school years, making it a preferred choice for families concerned about college transcripts. Finally, unlike many traditional programs that rely on worksheets, SMH uses 'living books' and narrations, which means the parent will spend more time sourcing specific books and less time grading repetitive busywork.

Getting Started