What Reviewers Say

Ellen McHenry's Science is consistently lauded by reviewers for its unique ability to teach high-level scientific concepts—often typically reserved for high school or college—to upper elementary and middle school students. Platforms like Cathy Duffy Reviews and The Homeschool Mom highlight the 'meaty' content that remains accessible through games, skits, and catchy songs. The curriculum is praised for being exceptionally creative and 'secular-friendly,' focusing on pure science with a neutral tone. However, because the curriculum is organized into short, deep-dive units (like 'The Elements' or 'The Brain') rather than a comprehensive year-long survey, some parents find they need to piece together several units to form a full year's credit. A common minor critique is the 'homemade' aesthetic of some materials, but users emphasize that the educational quality far outweighs the visual presentation. It is widely considered a gold standard for gifted learners and those who thrive on interactive, multi-sensory instruction.

How It Works

A parent and child typically work through one chapter per week, spending about 45 to 60 minutes over two or three sessions at the kitchen table. The parent facilitates by reading the meaty, high-level text aloud or monitoring the child's reading, then transitions into the curriculum's signature active learning phase, which might involve playing a custom board game about the periodic table or performing a short skit about cellular respiration. Most lessons utilize simple materials like scissors, tape, and colored pencils to assemble intricate paper models of things like the brain or a DNA strand. This approach turns complex scientific vocabulary into physical, multi-sensory crafts and games rather than relying on standard worksheets or drill-and-kill exercises.

Switching to This?

There are no formal placement tests, as the curriculum is organized into modular units like 'The Elements' or 'The Brain' rather than grade-specific textbooks. Families generally choose a topic based on interest, though the community rule of thumb is to start with 'The Elements' for students in grades 4-8 who are new to the series. Because each unit is self-contained and lasts between 8 to 12 weeks, families can easily start a module mid-year or use them to supplement a more traditional, dry textbook. Parents switching from a standard science program should be prepared for a significant jump in academic level; while the activities look like 'play,' the vocabulary and concepts are often equivalent to high school or college introductory courses.

Curriculum Details

Price

$14 - $39

Individual units are sold as digital downloads (typically $14.95-$19.95) or physical paperbacks (typically $25.00-$39.95) via Amazon or Lulu.

Grades

4 - 12

Available As

Digital Print Video Workbook

Coverage

Single subject

Subjects

Science Art

---

Pacing

Flexible

Parent Time

20-45 min/day

Parent Involvement

Minimal

Student Independence

Semi-independent

---

Academic Level

Advanced

Worldview

Neutral

Teach Multiple Ages

Yes

Engaging for Reluctant Learners

Yes

Videos

Reviews We Consulted

Updated: March 2026

How This Compares

Compared to R.E.A.L. Science Odyssey by Pandia Press, which provides a structured, full-year sequence with traditional labs, McHenry focuses on 'deep-dive' units that allow students to master one specific niche of science at a time. When weighed against Real Science-4-Kids, which features professional, polished graphics, McHenry has a more 'homemade' aesthetic that parents overlook in favor of its much more creative, hands-on activities like songs and skits. Parents choosing between McHenry and Sassafras Science will find that while Sassafras uses a fictional story to teach concepts, McHenry uses direct instruction paired with high-energy games and models. Against Guest Hollow, which is a curated schedule of external books and videos, McHenry provides the original text and all necessary activity templates in one self-contained package. For families with gifted learners, McHenry is often favored over secular counterparts because it respects the child's intelligence by teaching complex chemistry or neurology without watering down the terminology.