What Reviewers Say

Reviewers consistently praise Shurley English for its unique "Question and Answer Flow" and catchy jingles that help students internalize parts of speech. Cathy Duffy highlights the program's rigor and logical structure but notes it is teacher-intensive. While users on The Homeschool Mom appreciate the mastery of sentence parsing, some find the repetition tedious or the script too rigid. A common concern is the daily time requirement for parents, as the program is not designed for independent study. However, for parents seeking a structured, auditory-friendly approach to grammar that ensures long-term retention, Shurley English is often cited as a gold standard in the homeschool community.

How It Works

Each day, the parent reads from a scripted teacher’s manual to guide the child through a 20- to 45-minute lesson centered on oral interaction at the kitchen table. The session typically begins with catchy jingles played from a CD or digital file that help the student memorize parts of speech, followed by the 'Question and Answer Flow' where the parent and child orally parse sentences together using a specific script. After the oral portion, the child completes a short practice page in their workbook to apply these classification skills independently while the parent checks for immediate accuracy. Because the program relies heavily on these rhythmic patterns and back-and-forth dialogue, it requires the parent to be physically present and active for the entire duration of the lesson.

Switching to This?

Shurley Instructional Materials does not provide a formal placement test, so parents typically choose the level that matches their child’s current grade level. Because the curriculum builds a unique vocabulary and set of habits from the first chapter, it is best to start at the beginning of a book rather than trying to jump in mid-year. Families should be aware that the content repeats significantly between levels, so a common community rule of thumb is to use every other book (such as Levels 3, 5, and 7) to avoid burnout while still mastering the material. If you are switching from a program that does not use sentence parsing, expect a period of adjustment while your child learns the specific 'Question and Answer' script used to identify nouns, verbs, and adjectives.

Curriculum Details

Price

$75 - $250

Homeschool kits (Print) typically cost around $85-95 per level. Digital subscriptions are available annually for approximately $75.

Grades

1 - 8

Available As

Print Workbook Digital Audio

Coverage

Single subject

Subjects

Reading/Language Arts Writing

---

Pacing

Fixed schedule

Parent Time

30-45 min/day

Parent Involvement

Moderate

Student Independence

Needs instruction

---

Academic Level

Above grade level

Worldview

Neutral

Engaging for Reluctant Learners

Yes

Videos

Reviews We Consulted

Updated: March 2026

How This Compares

Compared to First Language Lessons, which uses a gentle classical approach with poetry and narration, Shurley English is much more systematic and clinical, focusing heavily on the technical breakdown of sentence structure. When weighed against Easy Grammar, the key difference is student independence; Easy Grammar allows a child to work through a workbook alone by first identifying prepositions, whereas Shurley requires a parent to lead a vocal dialogue to identify parts of speech. Parents looking at Fix It! Grammar will find that it uses real-world editing within a story, while Shurley uses specific practice sentences designed to drill grammar rules through repetition. Against Analytical Grammar, Shurley is better suited for younger students who benefit from multi-sensory tools like jingles, while Analytical Grammar is geared toward middle schoolers who want to master grammar in short, intensive bursts. For families choosing between Shurley and a comprehensive program like Logic of English, Shurley focuses strictly on grammar mechanics and writing, whereas Logic of English is an all-in-one approach that includes phonics and spelling. This makes Shurley the better choice for a parent who already has a preferred reading program but needs a separate, high-rigor grammar supplement.

Getting Started